A blog for Catholic men that seeks to encourage virtue, the pursuit of holiness and the art of true masculinity.
What is Truth? Discerning What is Real from Propaganda
January 28, 2019
But the serpent said to the woman, “You will not die. For
God knows that when you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be
like God, knowing good and evil.” Genesis 3:2
Pilate said to him, “What is truth?” John 18:38
“The 1640’s in England were the propaganda years, when myth
became truth because so many believed only what they wanted to believe.”
On January 18, 2019, a group of Catholic high school students from Covington, Kentucky, were standing near the Lincoln Memorial in Washington, D.C. They were waiting for their bus to pick them up and take them back to their hotel. They were in the capital, for the March for Life, which had taken place earlier that day. Nearby, a handful of very foul-mouthed men, who call themselves the Black Hebrew Israelites (BHI’s), berate a larger group of Native Americans who had gathered nearby to rally and march in the Indigenous Peoples March. Some of the teenagers began to watch the BHI’s. Some of the students, who were predominately white, and all of whom were male because Covington Catholic is an all-male school, were wearing “Make America Great Again” hats. Video of the incident shows that the only people who appeared to be offended by the hats were the BHI’s, who began to berate the teenage boys.
The BHI’s then began inciting the Native Americans to
confront the teenage boys. After about an hour of this, the teenagers began
chanting their school cheers and singing their school song, which drowned out
the verbal harassment from the BHI’s. Once the singing and chanting of the
teenagers ebbed, a group of Native Americans, led by Nathan Phillips, a
longtime left-wing political activist, walked across the courtyard of the
Lincoln Memorial, toward the teenagers, as numerous followers filmed everything
on their smart phones and video cameras. At first, the teenagers believed that
the group of Native Americans had approached them to join the chanting and
singing which had successfully drowned out the foul-mouthed harassment from the
BHI’s. However, after a few moments, it became more evident that Mr. Phillips
was using the teenagers in order to draw attention to himself and his political
agenda. The teenagers didn’t quite grasp this. Most of them remained unaware or
confused due to their lack of experience with things like propaganda which is
central to political activism.
As Nathan Phillips beat his drum and chanted a Native
American hymn, the teenagers stood and watched. Some chanted with him, some
videotaped it on the cell phones and others laughed and talked with their
classmates. One boy, the boy Mr. Phillips had chosen as his focal point, stood
and watched Mr. Phillips as Mr. Phillips beat his drum and chanted right in his
face. Mr. Phillips had walked several hundred yards to stand within ten to twelve
inches of the boy, which is well past the edge of the comfort zone of most
The teenagers did not touch Mr. Phillips, they did not
insult him, they did not belittle him, nor did they harass him in any other
way. However, the BHI’s had been yelling extreme insults at Mr. Phillips and
his fellow Native Americans for over an hour by that time.
Shortly after the incident, people began posting short clips
of videos in an effort to portray the teenagers as the aggressors. Some,
including Mr. Phillips, said that the teenagers had surrounded Mr. Phillips.
Celebrities began condemning the teenagers, some of whom promoted violence
toward the teenagers and posted their names and where they could be found. Even
clergy and lay leaders in the Catholic Church quickly condemned and criticized
the teenagers for what they assumed was disrespectful and embarrassing
behavior. Critics include the Bishop of the Covington diocese, which is the
diocese in which the high school exists, as well as the administration of the
No one seemed to be interested in the first hour or so of
facts which led up to the short video of Mr. Phillips standing in front of the
group of teenagers. In essence, everyone condemned the teenagers, even those
who had the duty to care for them on a school-sponsored pilgrimage.
Slowly, more video started to show up on social media. The
additional video showed the BHI’s foul-mouthed attacks on the Native Americans
and the teenagers. The new video showed that Mr. Phillips had walked all the
way across the mall to position himself directly in the face of the teenage boy,
and directly in front of all of the teenagers. The new video provided
perspective that only supported the innocence of the teenagers and more clearly
showed the manipulation and dishonesty of Mr. Phillips, the BHI’s and those who
had been promoting the persecution of the teenagers.
Unfortunately, many people don’t care if the teenagers are
innocent. Some who were quick to condemn them have apologized, others have simply
deleted their comments, but some refuse to withdraw their comments and
apologize, and others insist that the teenagers were in the wrong and should be
punished. Mr. Phillips continues to claim that he was the victim, and the BHI’s
have either remained silent, or no one will dare approach them to get their
perspective due to their extremely aggressive, offensive, anti-Christian, and antisocial
We must never cooperate with dishonesty, especially
dishonesty which is specifically tailored to victimize children. Rushing to the
defense of anyone is a perilous decision but rushing to the defense of an adult
who is confronting teenagers is simply foolish, especially when that adult is a
seasoned left-wing activist. People wonder why anyone would prefer dishonesty,
manipulation, and propaganda, over the truth.
Then I picked up my copy of St. Augustine’s confessions, and
the answer was right before my eyes:
“Why does truth call forth hatred? Why is Your servant treated as an enemy by those to whom he preaches the truth, if happiness is loved, which is simply joy in truth? Simply because truth is loved in such a way that those who love some other thing want it to be the truth, and precisely because they do not wish to be deceived, are unwilling to be convinced that they are deceived. Thus they hate the truth for the sake of that other thing which they love because they take it for truth. They love truth when it enlightens them, they hate truth when it accuses them. Because they do not wish to be deceived and do wish to deceive, they love truth when it reveals itself, and hate it when it reveals them.”
Still, I wondered why and how, well-meaning people sometimes
get sucked into promoting propaganda and misinformation, which makes these
well-meaning people little more than pawns. Then I read this:
"The first duty of the propagandist is to win over people who can subsequently be taken into the organization… The second duty of the organization is to disrupt the existing order of things and thus make room for the penetration of the new teaching which it represents, while the duty of the organizer must be to fight for the purpose of securing power, so that the doctrine may finally triumph."
The doctrine of the progressive liberal ideology has won the
minds of many people. Many of these people are highly placed in our colleges
and universities, as well as the media, entertainment industries. Lately it has
become evident that there are several very influential Catholics who have been
won over by the propaganda of progressive liberal ideology. This is where it is
most dangerous because it threatens to disrupt the existing order of the
teachings of the Church, where in Hitler’s words, it could penetrate “the new
teaching which it represents”.
At least one bishop, a Catholic school administration, and
other well-known Catholic theologians, educators, media personalities, and
commentators across the country rushed to the aid of a liberal progressive
activist who has used Catholic teenagers as things through which to triumph.
Not only this, they do so as quickly as the liberal progressive propagandists
who hate the Church. This is nothing less than influential Catholics showing
that they desire to be appreciated and popular more than they desire the truth.
In doing this, they worship false gods, making themselves fools.
Claiming to be wise, they became fools; and they exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images resembling a mortal human being or birds or four-footed animals or reptiles. Therefore God gave them up in the lusts of their hearts to impurity, to the degrading of their bodies among themselves, because they exchanged the truth about God for a lie and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever! Amen. Romans 1:22-25
Let this be a lesson to the influential Catholics in the United States and elsewhere. Some of you are being used like pawns, by propaganda artists who have gained their skills by learning from Satan himself.
Bob and his wife Carmen are the parents of five daughters. Bob practices law in Hastings, Nebraska, where he and his family are members of St. Cecilia parish. Bob has had pieces published by Catholic Answers Magazine, Crisis Magazine, Those Catholic Men, and he writes a regular column for the Southern Nebraska Register, the newspaper for the Diocese of Lincoln. Bob is a 4th Degree Knight of Columbus and he speaks at parishes and other public venues on matters such as apologetics, evangelization, the law, and the culture. Bob’s blog page is www.bsullivan.org, and you can follow him on Twitter and Facebook.
Warren H. Carroll, “The Cleaving of Christendom” pg. 581
St. Augustine, “Confessions” 2nd Edition by Sheed & Brown, pg.